Separated by Borders, United by Blood: Two Chilling Tales of Honor, Control, and Femicide in India & Pakistan

In a world increasingly shaped by smartphones and online fame, the stories of two young women -- one from Punjab, India, and another from Quetta, Pakistan -- serve as a haunting reminder that patriarchal violence not recognize any boundaries. Though these two cases are separated by borders, the two incidents are united by the reason why these two people were killed. Both the cases expose the dark side of cultures where a woman’s freedom is still seen as a danger to family pride.

Punjab's ‘Kaur Bhabhi’: Fame Turned Fatal

Komal Kaur, who came to be known as “Kaur Bhabhi” on social media, was a popular figure in the reels world of Instagram and TikTok. A mother of two, draped in vibrant dupattas and often using folk music, she showed the confident and bold image of a modern Punjabi woman. Her followers were increasing rapidly. But behind all the glamorized videos was a very fragile domestic set-up.

Komal had reportedly left her in-laws' house and moved back to her parental home after facing marital issues with her husband. In videos, many viewers saw captions which were cryptic and tones which very subtly showed signs of her distress hidden under layers of makeup and artistic nuances. Then came the shocking news that Komal was murdered, allegedly by her husband and his family. Police investigation revealed a horrifying truth: her popularity and public image was considered dishonor. The videos she made were seen as ''immoral'', ''inappropriate'' and ''not good'' for women in traditional homes.

Her sudden death shocked her followers. What was worse was the familiarity of narrative -- women get punished for being visible, bold, and not sorry for it. Even though she was a mother and grown-up woman, she did not allow society to dictate the way she had to live.

Quetta’s TikTok Influencer: Killed by Her Own Blood

Across the border in Quetta, Pakistan, another young TikTok girl had to face a similar fate, but the people who killed her were even closer. The 19-year-old girl, who had become popular for her online content, was murdered by her own parents in a case of so-called ''honor killing''. Her crime was that she was making videos dancing and lip-syncing to trending songs, something which many youths everywhere do everyday.

But her parents felt shame from her fame and ''bad attention'' she was getting. Reports say after many warnings and emotional blackmailing, her parents fixed the issue in their own way, by ending her life. They thought this would save them from ''dishonour'' which their daughter brought home. Her body was hidden and buried secretly, and only after some anonymous messages, police found the real truth.

After the murder, social media went crazy. Some conservative people said that her onscreen presence was ''too bold'' for a girl in a Muslim family, while others demanded justice. Feminist voices all over Pakistan raised questions about the growing number of honor killings being hidden behind culture and religion.

In one strange twist, after Komal Kaur’s killing went viral, some comments from Pakistan even supported the murder. And, the justification was the same as it was in Pakistan. One comment, now deleted, from a Pakistani user said the husband did good for saving his honor, and called Komal's videos “bad for family respect''. While many women activists from India and Pakistan condemned these statements, it showed how violence mindset don't belong to just one country -- it is a part of one dangerous culture that consider women’s freedom and their way of living as threat to society.

Common Threads: Control, Reputation, and Misogyny

India and Pakistan are enemies politically and divided by thick borders, but both of these stories show one very similar truth -- the strong desire in society to control life and choices of women, especially when they start to ''showing or exposing'' themselves in public.

In both the cases, it was not fame that came later. It was the fame that caused hatred and anger. Both women used their voices, looks, and talent to show their identity in front of everyone, and this was not accepted by the men and family members. For many people, a public platform is a place of success --but for these women, it became the reason for killing.

It is not surprising that both of them were involved in short-form entertainment and not politics or  religion topics. They made just simple content and spread happiness. But even this little self-expression is dangerous when patriarchy feels fear. And that fear leads to such a terrible end for the women who dare to carve a niche of their own in this crude world.

HOME